Homepage
Related Photos
Discussion
LeGrande competency debated
Sunday, May 6, 2007 — Convicted murderer Guy Tobias LeGrande returned to court shortly before 9:30 a.m. Friday in Stanly County to begin the next, and possibly last, leg of his journey toward legal recognition of his competence – or lack thereof.
Following his last court appearance in November LeGrande was sent by Judge Robert Bell to Dorothea Dix Hospital in Raleigh for a psychiatric evaluation of no more than 60 days to return after which for a competency hearing.
That decision came just days before LeGrande’s slated execution date.
Since his arrest more than a decade ago for the shotgun slaying of 26-year-old Ellen Munford, LeGrande has maintained he’s innocent of the crime.
In the years following his arrest and subsequent conviction for the homicide, questions have lingered regarding whether or not LeGrande was fit to represent himself, and more recently, whether or not he is fit for execution.
In what figures to possibly be among the final steps in identifying LeGrande’s mental fitness and competence, law enforcement and court officials along with attorneys and other expert witnesses gathered for the hearing.
With Albemarle police officers blocking Second Street, they and Stanly County Sheriff’s deputies directing lingering motorists away, two state prisoner transport cruisers arrived at the courthouse, LeGrande caged in the back of one of them.
The small convoy entered a veritable net of deputies before the prisoner was helped to his feet wearing shackles and chains and was immediately escorted to the courthouse by deputies and three state agents.
Those agents never left his side and deputies stationed themselves at appointed posts in the courthouse and courtroom.
The behavior and character of the defendant were initially reviewed and explored through witnesses’ experiences with him.
After attorneys and other professionals who worked on his behalf in the past delivered sworn testimony recounting their interactions with LeGrande, Bell addressed him directly.
Often smiling, but at times using profanity, LeGrande’s responses in the hearing leaned occasionally in the direction of competence and lucid high intelligence, while in other instances it was confusing and difficult to follow.
Brief coherent recitals of state statutes and legal jargon were shaded with seemingly irrelevant tangents that seldom approached actual answers to questions he fielded from Bell.
A bizarre tension solidified in the courtroom more than once as the silence from the gallery and court officials was broken up by lengthy and circular discourses from LeGrande.
Although he is facing capital punishment, LeGrande spent the majority of his time in the courtroom with a relaxed appearance, partially reclined in an office-style chair, swiveling slightly as the events of his hearing unfolded.
LeGrande seemed to be detached from the proceedings, he often made declarations that he was simply a “conscientious observer.”
His rebuke of suggestions of being beyond eccentric prompted a question from Bell at one point during the hearing. Bell asked LeGrande if he actually wanted to be executed.
One question that pulled a concise response from LeGrande dealt with the nature of the events of the day.
“Why are we here today?” Bell asked him, to which LeGrande replied, “You’re trying to see whether or not I’m competent.”
After statements mocking testimony that he seemed to operate in a “parallel universe,” LeGrande outlined a simple description of his perceived future.
“There’s only two ways it can go,” he said. “Either I’ll be executed or I’ll go free.”
During his initial trial he addressed the jury wearing a Superman T-shirt, he mixed foul language with discombobulated rants, and he’s petitioned government officials from prison using grandiose self references.
But when questioned about his own sense of competence, LeGrande insisted he’s aware of his situation and the world around him.
However, in one letter he wrote, he opened with, “From the Constitutional and Civil Rights Office of the Director for the National Coalition of Black Secret Agents Enslaved at Central Prison,” and went on to state his plights – both perceived and actual.
He scoffed at references to comments he’d been attributed with uttering such as descriptions of anvils falling from the sky and sought to lend them credibility.
“When I make these little conundrums; these riddles, I’m alluding to another situation,” he said.
While his intentions can be interpreted various ways, LeGrande claimed the obscure phrases and scribbling he’s accountable for are his way of communicating.
Late in the hearing, which wrapped up around 3:40 p.m., LeGrande responded to a question about the administrative exchange of power from former North Carolina Gov. Jim Hunt to current Gov. Mike Easley.
It was predicated on something LeGrande was quoted as having said in reference to the exchange, which involved the passing of a cup.
When asked to explain his comments that the exchange was symbolic of his own experiences he talked about a N.C. Department of Correction employee who told him it was “tea time at the jail.”
Afterwards he suggested the man must have a propensity for Extra-Sensory Perception (ESP).
When Bell questioned the relevance of the anecdote, LeGrande quoted him as having asked, “Mr. Crow, you asked for a cup of water didn’t you?”
The attorney defending LeGrande, whom LeGrande does not acknowledge as his legal council, Jay Ferguson, will present expert witnesses when the hearing reconvenes in about a month.
That portion of the hearing may include further examination of a letter Ferguson entered into evidence Friday.
The letter, composed to several attorneys by James H. Hilkey, PhD, Psychologist, suggests competency determination is a more complex issue than most realize and a lack of proper examination can result in errors.
He goes on to say, “Mr. LeGrande may be suffering from a significant mental disorder.”
- Homepage
-
-
APD investigates woman’s death
Albemarle Police Depart-ment is conducting a death investigation after responding to an emergency medical call at the magistrate’s office Tuesday.
At 9:33 a.m., a medical call was received from the magistrate’s office. An APD officer responded along with Emergency Medical Services (EMS) personnel - Missing child found moments after alert issued
- Stanly 4-H consists of many programs
-
APD investigates woman’s death
- Local News
-
-
Fair opens tonight
Rides, games, music and more hit the Stanly County Fairgrounds tonight in the form of the 76th annual Stanly County Fair, sponsored by American Legion Post 76. This year, the rides will be put on by J&J Amusements.
- Even though deadline has passed, SCS still accepts donations
- Albemarle Police Report
- Stanly County Sheriff’s Report
- Pedestrians, motorists urged to be cautious at Pfeiffer
-
- Sports
-
-
Albemarle, North renew their rivalry
The last season that the North Stanly football program enjoyed a victory over rival Albemarle was back in 1993, when the Comets blanked the Bulldogs 20-0.
Jack Gaster was in his first year as head coach of Albemarle with a squad that year that had just seven seniors, compared to Dick Gresham’s squad that had 16 seniors - The rules not found in print are open to varied analysis
- Women’s Soccer’s Sara McCormick
-
- Lifestyles
-
-
Smith-Bowman Engagement
Ceb Sidney Smith of Stanfield and Starla Thomas Smith of Albemarle announce the engagement of their daughter, Jessica Marie Smith of Stanfield to Zachary Floyd Bowman of Stanfield, son of Floyd Bowman of New London and Lisa Morrison Bowman of Stanfield.
- Brookses celebrate 65th anniversary
- Couple celebrates Golden Anniversary
-
- Around Stanly County
-
-
Goody’s makes its return to Albemarle
The Stanly County Chamber of Commerce held a ribbon cutting Wednesday for the re-opening of Goody’s in Albemarle.
A large crowd was in attendance for the 9 a.m. opening.
“I’m very excited. Looks like we have a great turnout. Hopefully we’ll have some great success here,” Store Manager Randy Roberts said - Kissell helps open new development
-
- Opinion
-
-
Five effective study skills for successful school year
The first day back to school can be a source of anxiety for both children and parents as they adjust to new routines, new teachers and friends, forthcoming homework assignments and, ultimately, tests.
To help parents and students kick-start the new school year successfully, Sylvan Learning-Albemarle offers five critical steps to help families make learning fun and easy. - Support the fair
- Accurate, fair, unbiased reporting
-
- Features
-
-
Stanly Health Services conducts back-to-school backpack drive
The employees of Stanly Health Services collected 139 backpacks for children in need across Stanly County.
Staff members from Stanly Regional, Stanly Manor, Stanly Medical Services, Home Care of the Carolinas and Alliance Medical, Inc. were encouraged to participate in the month-long campaign by dropping off new backpacks in large green bins located at each facility. - 11-year-old gets hair cut for Locks of Love
-
- Nascar News
- Letters to the Editor
-
-
Boat safe, boat sober
The end of summer is quickly approaching. One of the last big weekends for boating is the Labor Day holiday.
All of us want to go on the water and have fun with our family and friends, but there are a few things we need to always keep in mind. - We should be pro-business
- Many make School Tools Ride successful
-
Boat safe, boat sober
- Service News
-
-
Guard Soldiers Return from Iraq
RALEIGH, N.C. – The North Carolina National Guard’s 113th Finance Detachment, 130th Financial Management Company, headquartered in Siler City, returned after deploying for Operation Iraqi Freedom in October 2009 to North Carolina at Raleigh-Durham International Airport in Raleigh Aug. 19.
- NC Air Guard Participates in Emergency Exercise
- Moldovan Military Members Visit NCNG
-
- Entertainment
-
-
Fair arrives in town
The 76th Stanly American Legion Post #76 Agricultural Fair Inc. Presents J&J Amusements. Fun for the whole family. September 2-Monday, September 6 at the Stanly County Fairgrounds.
- Eat, Pray, Love Movie Trailer
-
